221. The Supreme Court of India

221

A CALM JUDGEMENT

     The last mail was submitted to His Excellency the President of India on 5 May 2013. The same mail was sent to the Supreme Court of India, Indian Army and Indian Air Force.   Later, it was sent through post to the President of India and the Chief Justice of India; and posted in the blog www. howeverythinghappenedinindia.blogspot.com

       A Bench of the Supreme Court of India comprising Justices R.M. Lodha, Madan B. Lockur and Kurian Joseph, on 6 May 2013, asked the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) to tell the reason for consulting the accused officials in the Government. The CBI tendered an apology.

         Then the Bench said that even the Prime Minister of India cannot interfere with the course of investigation. Describing the CBI as a "caged parrot", it asked the Government to come out with a law before 10 July 2013 to insulate the CBI from external influences.

     As a result, the Union Law Minister, Mr. Ashwani Kumar, resigned.

   A Group of Ministers (GoM) under the chairmanship of Finance Minister P. Chithambaram was constituted to make the CBI an autonomous institution.

     It must be noted that the CBI, in the pretext of an autonomous institution, brought down the Deve Gowda Government as narrated in Chapter 18 of www. primeministerdevegowda.blogspot.com

     In contrast, Chapter 7 of www.vajpayee.blogspot.com shows how the very breath of the then Prime Minister sent the officers of the CBI  to Chennai.

    The police could do anything in good faith and not in bad faith.

    One day, a petitioner and inpatient told the doctor that he was beaten by one person. But an IPS officer added one more person. The case is going on for the last 15 years. Even the finding of the Human Rights Commission has no meaning to the courts.

     Therefore, the CBI –and even the Supreme Court- must work under the order and direction of  a democratically elected government because it cannot do anything illegal.

     

      A Supreme Court bench comprising K.S. Radhakrishnan and Dipak Misra, on 6 May 2013, gave conditional green signal to Kudankulam nuclear power plant. Justice Dipak Misra cautioned that the plant should not be made operational before getting final clearance from the competent authorities. Thus the plant may not be opened in the near future.

     China, on 7 May 2013, retreated from the recently intruded places.

    However, Army Chief Vikram Singh is silent over this matter. He must disclose the truth.

    He must also tell whether the soldiers recruited after 2003 are under the old pension rule or not.

     Further, he could go through www. storyofananthapadmanabhan.blogspot.com to study the heroic deeds of Ananthapadmanabhan.

 

       About 150 officials of the Department of Income Tax conducted searches on the GRT Jewellery outlets in Chennai on May 12 and 13.

      The GRT got the license to buy and sell gold. It is not a secret matter.

     It would not hesitate to pay salary to two or three officers deputed by the Government. But it would not relish the raids like this one.

    Therefore, the government should use its power in good faith and supervise all entities having more than a certain maximum transaction. Then the officers alone would go to jail. Let this raid be the last one in India.

    Mr. A. K. Antony, Defence Minister, said that a revolution of sorts would happen in the country. The New Indian Express reported this on 16 May 2013.

     A revolution has already happened because of this work. As there is no freedom, the people are not aware of it.

   Delhi police arrested cricket player Sreesanth, on 16 May 2013, on the suspicion that he was involved in the so-called spot fixing.

         About 25 others - players and the so-called bookies - were also arrested.

     The police covered the face of Sreesanth while taking him into custody. He is in jail.

    But he said that he was innocent.

    Yet the police booked him under section 409 of the IPC (criminal breach of trust by agent that entails life imprisonment). For this they recovered even his clothes besides lap-tops and others.

    But when the police got concrete evidence against Gurunath Meiyappan, son in law of President of Board of Control for Cricket in India Mr. Srinivasan, it did not arrest him. It did not enter his house. It did not even touch his clothes. Instead, it retreated.

   Apparently, the police obtained prior permission from Prime Minister Manmohan Singh for arresting Sreesanth and not Meiyappan.  Earlier, he had allowed the police to arrest Telecom Minister A. Raja and not his predecessor, Mr. Arun Shourie.

       However, this matter continues to be the headline news for the newspapers and TV channels all over India.

     The police did not admonish the players when it stumbled upon this matter. Instead, it spent 6 months to investigate the matter.

    In contrast, despite several letters:

1.              Prime Minister Manmohan Singh illegally gave Re. 3 lakh crore in the Provident Fund (PF) to private parties.

2.              When former Prime Minister Mr. A.B. Vajpayee handed over the public sector HZL to Vedanta in violation of all rules, the people thought that he had given a shield worth Re.500/- only. Now its annual income is more than Re.10,000 crore!

3.               Former President asked the Supreme Court to give a reply to this work. But no reply is its reply. Any other authority could have done this and not the Supreme Court.

   Evidently, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh - misusing his power - is making very small matters into very big matters and vice versa. He is doing this to conceal the illegalities committed by him and his predecessor.

   Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, on 16 May 2013, put his movable and immovable assets at 12 crore.

    But the political power in his hand is worth more than 12 lakh crore.

    A Supreme Court of India Bench comprising K.S. Radhakrishnan and Dipak Misra said that the court would interfere in the economic policy only if it is illegal. The Bench used a very long sentence to say this and justified the Cairan-Vedanta deal.

      The Bench should have declared freedom before talking like this. It did not do so. Therefore, the predominant passion of the Supreme Court is the promotion of irregularities and illegalities.

    Reserve Bank of India (RBI) Governor Subbarao, on 8 May 2013, said that there were no evidence of money laundering in banks and insurance companies. He added that the customers must bear the risk.

     He had given Re. 3 lakh crore in the PF to private parties. Therefore, he cannot see money laundering in any place.

   In the last letter, the writer said that some governments were deducting medical insurance premium from the pensioners without sending the insurance cards and the list of hospitals. He is not ready to verify the veracity of the submission.

   Now, a customer of the LIC- Housing Finance Limited (LIC-HFL)  -No. 21460006967 -asked the basis for the calculation of penal interest and collection charges. There was no reply. A reminder was sent. Then also there was no reply. It- just like the Supreme Court – prefers not to send  any reply. This shows that the computers generate false values and the LIC-HFL is laundering Re. thousands of crore.

     The RBI Governor could check it from his own chamber and send a reply.

 

     The Supreme Court of India (SCI), on 8 May 2013, rejected the bail plea of Jagan Mohan Reddy. It asked the CBI to complete the investigation within four months. He had spent 1 year in jail.

     The charge was that his father, Mr. Y.S. Rajaasekar Reddy, had granted licences to some companies. The recipients, in return, invested money in the company of his sons.

    The act of granting licences is the actual illegality. But the government chose not to touch his father during his life time.

    Prime Minister Manmohan Singh gave public money and public assets to private parties because he got the post of the Prime Minister of India. It is not an offence! But what Mr. Jagan Mohan Reddy got is an offence! The Supreme Court of India is making very small matters into very big matters and vice versa.

   The Cognizant Technology Solutions (CTS), on 8 May 2013, said that that Mr. Sridhar would take over the role Chief Operating Officer (COC) from Mr. Coburn. The former, according to the news, would ensure that the company’s people functions were solid and scalable. The Hindu reported this on 9 May 2013.

    Is it the repercussion of the last letter? Did the CTS drop its idea to dismiss the employees?

     Prime Minister of China Mr. Li Keqiang paid a visit to India on 20 May 2013.

   He said that China would solve outstanding issues through direct talks. He wanted to put at rest the anxieties about unresolved issues that included border and water.

     With regard to the Indian unease over $30 billion annual trade deficit, he said:1. The Chinese companies would be asked to invest more in India and 2. Indian products will get greater access to the Chinese markets.

   His statement shows that India is a vassal of China.

    Later he paid a visit to the Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) at Mumbai and talked to the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI).

     He called on the relatives of legendary Indian physician, Dwarkanath Shantaram Kotnis also.

   Mrs. Susma Swaraj, a leader of the principal opposition party, the BJP, on 22 May 2013, said that Prime Minister Manmohan Singh looked to Mrs. Sonia Gandhi for every decision.

     They are better than Mahatma Gandhi. The leaders of the BJP actually worship them because they could successfully cover up the illegalities committed by the NDA government.

       Finance Minister Mr. P.Chithambaram, on 22 May 2013, said that a new law would be enacted to oversee the financial sector. This is the suggestion given by this writer. He has used the word “oversee” instead of “supervise”. He tells this because he has to obey. He must tell this to the people.

       However, if the government could undertake raids, it could very well supervise without any new law. A notification alone would be sufficient.

    The government must run all the sick and the closed institutions on a war footing. It must be noted that the SUS bank has not even returned the jewels of the people.

    

    The ideas do not occur in the mind of everyone. When a citizen captures some ideas, the Supreme Court must allow the people to evaluate them. This is the purpose of the Supreme Court.

    A calm judgement is needed for this.

     The facts from 5 May 2013 to 22 May 2013 are being submitted to His Excellency the President of India on 23 May 2013.

       The same letter is being sent to the Chief Justice of India and the Chiefs of the Indian Army and Indian Air Force for necessary action.

V. Sabarimuthu

26-3 Thattamkonam,Vellicode, Mulagumoodu PIN: 629167

Tamil Nadu State,

INDIA

Phone: 04651275520. Mobile: 9486214851

23 May 2013.

For further reading visit:

1.www. vajpayee.blogspot.com

2.www.primeministervajpayee.blogspot.com

3.www.primeministerdevegowda.blogspot.com

4.www.primeministermanmohansingh.blogspot.com



5. www.storyofananthapadmanabhan.blogspot.com

6.www.howeverythinghappenedinindia.blogspot.com

V. Sabarimuthu (2006)

Other blogs of this writer are:

1. www.temples-and-churches.blogspot.com

2. www. effectiveinorganicchemistry.blogspot.com

     

220. The Weakest Prime Minister

220

FIXING THE RESPONSIBILITY

       The last mail was submitted to His Excellency the President of India on 9 April 2013. The same mail was sent to the Supreme Court of India, Indian Army and Indian Air Force.   Later, it was sent through post to the President of India and the Chief Justice of India; and posted in the blog www. howeverythinghappenedinindia.blogspot.com

      BJP President Rajnath Singh, on 9 April 2013, ruled out an early announcement of the prime ministerial candidate of his party.

  Is this his response to the last letter?

    The Director, Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), on 13 April 2013, said that many complaints were pending in the CBI for want of sanction.

    The CBI has a higher master - in the form of the recipients of the Provident Fund - than its hard hearted political master. In fact, it acknowledges no higher principles than their orders. Therefore, no right thinking man would trust it.

      It is pertinent to recall that the then Director, CBI, Johinder Singh, one day, carried a brief case containing the “Bofors papers” at Geneva. The media repeatedly showed this all over the world. The CBI did not get the prior permission of the government for this. It could, thus, bring down the United Front (UF) Government led by Mr. H.D. Deve Gowda.

     In contrast, it is not ready to show even one out of the 219 letters for the freedom of the people.

    Should the CBI seek the permission of the government to inform the existence of this work to the people?

    India got $69 billion in remittances in 2012, the highest in the world, followed by China with $64 billion.

  This enables some industrial houses and others to siphon off money to other countries.

    Union Government, on 21April 2013, decided to accord ‘Z’ category security to Chairman of Reliance Industries Mr. Mukesh Ambani.

       He is one of the directing minds of the nation. The decision was taken by him. Perhaps, he deserves this for his experience in running some companies.

    Godrej Group Chairman Adi Godrej, in an interview to The Hindu, said that his company would grow ten-fold in ten years. The paper reported this on 22 April 2013.

        It must have the strength to grow in an atmosphere of freedom.

    China, on 21April 2013, air dropped Made-in- China articles in Chumar- a town on the Indian side of the Indo-Tibet border.

    China –in order to achieve its objectives- is ready for the free supply of all finished products to every Indian for five years.

     In a letter to the Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) former Telecom Minister A. Raja, on 22 April 2013, linked all key decisions to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Finance Minister P. Chithambaram.

    There can be nothing worse than the jail term suffered by him.  He need not talk about the things known to everyone.

       The Hindu, on 23 April 2013, said that policies should be subjected to democratic processes and be responsive to the aspirations of the people.

   The paper deprives the people of their freedom. At the same time, it talks like this. Therefore, its assets belong to the people.

   The Supreme Court of India Bench comprising K.S. Radhakrishnan and T.S. Khehar, on 23 April 2013, told the promoter of the Sahara,   Subrata Roy, that he was manipulating the court.

    The court should have directed the government to run all his companies. This is for the compliance of its own order. Until then he would continue to manipulate the court.

  

     China intruded 20 km into the India territory in the Ladakh region. Defence Minister A.K. Antony said that India would take every step to protect its interests. The newspapers and TV channels reported this on 23 April 2013.

  But China said that the new camp at Ladakh was there for the long term.

   Does China want Indian Defence Minister A.K. Antony to quit the Union Cabinet as part of the so-called Antony Centred Politics (ACP)?

   China had given Re.30,000 crore to an industrialist in India. He might now help solve this problem.

   Curiously, Army Chief Vikram Singh does not talk about the intrusion. He may be helpless in this matter.

    But, he could ensure full salary and pension to the soldiers.

    He could also make Ananthapadmanabhan mentioned in the last chapter as a model of the Indian Army after studying his heroic deeds.

     Mr. Ratan Tata, on13 April 2007, said that his companies were creating wealth only to give back to the people. He disclosed that his family was holding just 2 percent of the shares of Tata Sons. He added that 60 percent of wealth created by him went for charity.

     None would mistrust him. But, his statement is an incredible one. Does he mean his personal wealth? He should not hesitate to substantiate his statement with facts and figures.     

        Police killed 15 militant people in the Chhattishgarh state on 17 April 2013. Had this work been shown to the people, this would not have occurred.

    

    Cognizant Technologies Solutions (CTS), on 17 April 2013, revealed that 480 employees would be terminated from service.

   Apparently, the company has taken this decision at the instance of other companies.

   Had this work been recognized for its exact worth, this would not have happened.

    If the system gives freedom, all employees of the software companies would not only get security of service but also direct payment of salary from the government.  

     Justices Vikramajit Sen and A.R. Dave of the Supreme Court of India rescued themselves from the Bench hearing the petitions of Mr. Sunil Bharti Mittal and Mr. Ravi Ruia in the 2G spectrum case.

    The petitioners are not like former Telecom Minister A. Raja. The principle of equality cannot be applied in this case. However, the learned judges must give reason for their action.

         On the same day, the CBI advised the Chief Justice of India to hear the case under a Bench headed by Justice Singhvi.

   Why does the CBI distinguish between Justice Singhvi, and others?

    Wipro Company Chairman Azim Premji, on 19 April 2013, said that he had given 25 percent of his wealth to charity.

    Charity must be with love. Charity devoid of love is useless. Therefore, charity must be after giving freedom

    Mr. Premji does not place his employees under any constraint consciously. However, they do not get proper sleep, food or exercise. Therefore, he could have recommended direct pension benefits from the government.

      A leaked report of the JPC said that Mr. A. Raja misled the Prime Minister Manmohan Singh.

    Tomorrow, everyone would say that Re.3 lakh crore in the Provident Fund (PF) went in the hand of private parties without his knowledge.

      A leader of the BJP, Mr. Arun Jaitely, on 19 April 2013, said that the government had subverted truth through the JPC.

    Mr. A. Raja convinced everyone that any deviation from the unconstitutional policy pursued by his predecessors in the NDA government would affect the new entrants. Therefore, the established players sent him to jail. Is it not the truth?

      Holding that Paramount Airways Private Limited had become insolvent, the Madras High Court, on 19 April 2013, appointed a liquidator and asked him to take charge of that company.

   This is another sad day for India. The courts must act constructively.

   The government, apparently, did not help this company as in the case of Jet Airways. Further, it did not supervise its functioning by sending necessary officers under deputation.

   Now, the government must run it. It is its duty.

    Saradha Group – a Chit Fund in the West Bengal state – had defrauded thousands of investors. It – like the Sahara Group – unloaded on the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) 230 boxes of documents.

      It is the right of an individual to run a chit fund. The government discharges its duty of issuing licence to him. Then it is the responsibility of the government to supervise it.

      Evidently, anyone would fix the responsibility on the government. Pending this, all failed entities - like the SUS bank in the Tamil Nadu state - must be taken over on a war footing and the grievances of the people redressed.

     The government should not consciously allow anyone to defraud anyone through any means –stock- market included. Instantaneous action is the need of the hour.

   A Supreme Court of India Bench comprising Chief Justice Altamas Kabir, Justice S.S. Nijjar and Justice Pinaki Chandra Ghose ordered that the hearing against Bharti Cellular Limited CMD Sunil Mittal and Essar Group promoter Ravi Ruia in the 2G Spectrum case would remain postponed until further orders.

    It is not customary for the higher courts to act like this that too without giving the reason. Until the acquittal of Mr.A.Raja, it is not fair to interfere in this way. This violates equality rule.

     It could have interfered after watching the unjust actions, if any, of the trial court.

    United India Insurance Company recorded profit after tax of Re.527 crore for the fiscal ended 2012-2013.

   There are demonstrations to secure the insured amount from the above company. This also happens due to the failure of the government to supervise it.

    Now, some state governments are deducting the health insurance premium from the pensioners without issuing the insurance card and the list of hospitals.

    A Bench of the Supreme Court of India comprising Justices R.M.Lodha,  Madan V. Lokur and Kurian Joseph, on 30 April 2013, said that they wanted to liberate the CBI to restore its position of impartiality. It added that the CBI need not take instructions from their political masters.

   The Supreme Court had talked like this in the so-called Jain Hawala case. It is given in Chapter 18 of www.primeministerdevegowda.blogspot.com

    Unlike in the past, the Director, CBI, on 1 May 2013, openly said that the CBI –(just like the Supreme Court)-was part of the system. He added that the CBI constantly consulted the government to take opinion.

    If allowed, he would have talked more.

   Does the CBI think that time have come for it to act?

   Union Minister for Finance Mr. P.Chithambaram requested the officials of the Directorate of Enforcement to be extremely careful while choosing cases for prosecution under the money laundering law. He added that the cases should not affect the investments.

     This was an idea given by this writer. He must tell this to the people. This is for the freedom of the people.

        Bharti Airtel, on 3 May 2013, disclosed its decision to sell 5 percent of its shares to Qatar Foundation Endowment for Re. $1.26 billion. A few other companies are also selling their assets for huge amounts.

     Everyone must pay stamp duty for buying property.

    Further, everyone must know the public character of the private companies in India.

   Furthermore, the government must note  that the assets of the Indian private companies in other countries belong to the government.

     The Businessline, on 3 May 2013, reported that there were 1500 vacancies for IAS officers. But the Government selected about 1000 officers only.

    In order to implement the suggestions present in this work, at least 10,000 more officers would be needed.

              Leader of the opposition Mr. L.K. Advani, on 3 May 2013, said that Dr. Manmohan Singh was the weakest Prime Minister of India.

   Prime Minister Manmohan Singh:

1.  Secretly gave Re.3 lakh crore in the PF to private parties.

2.  Allowed the recipients of the PF to generate black money.

3.  Appointed another person responsible for this as the President of India.

4.  Gave the money in the banks, LIC, Public Sector Undertakings to the recipients of the PF.

  5. Sent Mr. Ramalinga Raju –an industrialist- to jail.

   6. Handed over  Satyam Company  to another person.

7. Sent his  colleague - Mr. A Raja - to jail.

8. Sent Political leader Mr. Jagan Mohan Reddy to jail.

9. Sent many small industrialists to jail.

10. Sent many cases-like the Medical Council of India case-to oblivion

11. Liquidated the Dunlop India Private Limited.

12. Clipped the wings of Kingfisher Airlines.

13. Closed the Paramount Airways.

14. Allowed China to invade thousands of small industries through the manipulation of import duty.

15. Allowed China to sell cancer causing toys.

16. Approved the removal of government pension from the employees.

17. Talked about democracy and ballot while denying freedom.

   Thus, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh may not be as strong as Mahatma Gandhi. But, he is stronger than any other political leader in India – Mr. L.K. Advani included.

      Anyone going through this work would now fix the responsibility for this predicament on the Chief Justice of India because all others could disown responsibility.

     The facts from 9 April 2013 to 4 May 2013 are being submitted to His Excellency the President of India on 5 May 2013.

       The same letter is being sent to the Chief Justice of India and the Chiefs of the Indian Army and Indian Air Force for necessary action.

V. Sabarimuthu

26-3 Thattamkonam

Vellicode, Mulagumoodu PIN: 629167

Tamil Nadu State,

INDIA

Phone: 04651275520. Mobile: 9486214851

5 May 2013.


For further reading visit: 1. Chapter 7 of www.vajpayee.blogspot.com 

2.Chapter 7 of www.primeministervajpayee.blogspot.com
3. www.primeministerdevegowda.blogspot.com

V. Sabarimuthu ( A photo taken a few years ago)